Saturday, July 19, 2008

HEGEL SMILES: NEBRASKA'S NO FAULT DUMP

This is worth a second blog.

From today's Omaha World-Herald:

LINCOLN — Nebraska hospitals have no clue who they might find on their doorsteps when the state's unique "safe haven" law goes into effect Friday. It could be fragile newborns left by frightened and desperate young women. Or it could be unruly teenagers dropped off by frustrated parents.

It looks like the folks at the Nebraska Children's Home Society aren't too pleased about it:

Karen Authier, executive director of the Nebraska Children's Home Society adoption agency, (NOTE: a longtime vocal opponent of legal baby dumps) worries that such predictions are too optimistic.

She said her agency and others already have gotten disturbing calls from people talking about using the new law to drop off children who are more than a year old.

If they follow through, she said, their children could be badly traumatized by the experience.

"I hope this bill isn't misused," Authier said. "Because it's written so broadly, it could be misinterpreted as encouraging people to abandon children."

Sen. Pete Pirsch, the bill's sponsor admits that the laws takes a "unique approach," and

"To me, the important thing was to get through a safe haven bill," said Pirsch, adding that he doesn't expect problems because of the broader age range of Nebraska's law. He said parents typically call law enforcement if they have problems with their teens.

So true! But do parents really want the neighbors to see the cops at their door? The safe haven approach is much cleaner. Instead of having Biff tasered on the front porch by four large men in uniform or Buffy frog-marched to a limo by a gaggle of nuns, savvy parents can quietly drop off their unruly spawn to the calm nurturing cocoon of a hospital emergency room. And when the neighbors ask about them,parents can reply with confidence (and confidentiality) that Biff is at band camp or Buffy graduated early and is studying preference utilitarianism at Princeton with Peter Singer for the summer. Nobody will ever have to know!

BUT WAIT A MINUTE!

The Nebraska Department of Health and Human Services will take custody of safe haven children and treat those cases the same as other cases of abandonment, said Todd Landry, director of children and family services. That means trying to identify the child's parents and family and, if the parents can be found, assessing whether the child should be reunited with them. When parents cannot be found, the department will work to get the child placed for adoption as quickly as possible, Landry said.

I don't think this is what the safe haven recycling pimps had in mind, How can you expect to drop off Jayden and Harmony without the state's promise of anonymity and safety if those snoopy social workers come looking for you? Expect a spike in dumpster teens!

Hegel must be smiling.

President Grant once said "the best way to get rid of a bad law is to enforce it."
With this this is mind I offer an open invitation to all frustrated, tired, angry disgusted parents, wherever you are: take your unpleasant child in hand, hop in your car or on Greyhound (or a plane if TSA will let the delinquent through), and head for America's heartland. Make Nebraska the the child dump capital of America. Corn is so yesterday!

No fault baby dumping = the new adoption

Pete Pirsch is either a subversive or an idiot? You decide.

Thursday, July 17, 2008

NEBRASKA SAFE HAVEN LAW: TIRED OF YOUR KID?

You'll all be glad to know that Nebraska's "Baby" Safe Haven law goes into effect today. Note the quotation marks. They're important.

Unlike every other state that puts an age limit on dumping (3 days, 7 days, 1 month) the Nebraska legislature gives desperate killer parents a break. Nebraskans can dump their resident juvenile-of- any-age, as long as it's done in a politically correct manner --at a hospital. Unfortunately turning Biff and Buffy over to the cops will still get Mom and Dad a stay in the GrayBar Hotel.

This isn't new news. I wrote about Nebraska's odd safe haven take previously in Nebraska's New Baby Dump Law: Better than Ritilan. You can read the poorly written law here.

Read the KETV-Omaha report to get the full absurdity and ramifications:

The new law that takes effect Friday says that any individual can leave a minor with a hospital employee without fear of being charged with abandonment."Then it becomes a nurturing, supportive, helpful atmosphere versus criminal neglect or abuse-type atmosphere," Chambers said. (Deb Chambers is , the director of the Family Birth Center.)...

...The new law says anyone under the age of 19 can be dropped at a hospital. Hospital staff said they already have procedures in place to help children and the elderly, so they will keep using those to help any older children.

The child advocacy group Voices of Children, isn't impressed:

We hope the intent of the law, which is to be in the best interest of children, is followed, but we're not sure whether or not this is the best-designed policy to do that," Voices for Children policy coordinator Sarah Ann Lewis said. "We'd rather see mothers use the services already in the community, like adoption or counseling, instead of abandonment."

Actually on closer look, this isn't a "Baby Safe Haven" law at all. It's decriminalization of child abandonment dressed up in fashionable safe haven bombastia. It simply takes away the ability of prosecutors to prosecute abandonment as long as the left behind isn't abused. This, of course, is an option prosecutors have always had and used frequently until the baby dump set twisted prosecutorial discretion into anonymous baby dumping.

It would have been a simple matter for states to decriminalize "abandonment." Of course, it would have been perceived by the public as social decay and being soft on crime. Instead, safe haven advocates, reactionary adoption industry thugs pushing back adoptee rights, natural dads, and ICWA, along with a variety of bleeding heart do-gooders and media hounds, with agendas very different from decriminalization, pimped anonymous baby dumping as a way to "save babies," So far, they've been unable show us one baby actually "saved" from the dumpster. All we see is non-documented kids fast tracked into the adoption mill and potential child killers bribed off the hook.

It's 1:30 AM and I'm writing this on my porch . Down the street my obnoxious teenage neighbor is screaming at her boyfriend. She does this a lot. Sometimes, and I'm not making this up, she jumps up and down on the hood of his car--just in case he misses her point. Once I get this blog up I'm going to walk down there and offer her a free road trip to Omaha. She'll thank me for it some day. I mean, what's the alernative?


July 18, 7:05 PM ADDENDA: Phew! After I posted this entry I started to worry that maybe the hospital wouldn't accept my teenage neighbor into the Nebraska Safe Haven Program. After all, I'm not her mother. Thankfully, KOLN/KGIN (Grand Island) clarified this today:

The statute also states that a person only have "physical custody" of the child they're handing over, not "legal custody," so you don't have to be the child's parent or guardian.

NEBRASKA HERE WE COME!

Friday, February 29, 2008

NEBRASKA'S NEW BABY DUMP LAW: BETTER THAN RITALIN!

In case you missed it, Alaska and Nebraska finally went over to the dark side and legalized baby dumping recently. But in the case of the Nebraska law, it's fast-track child dumping. Child welfare workers and juvenile court judges are gonna love working with this one!

The law, outside of a two sentence intro, reads in full:

Section 1. No person shall be prosecuted for any crime based solely upon the act of leaving a child in the custody of an employee on duty at a hospital licensed by the State of Nebraska. The hospital shall promptly contact appropriate authorities to take custody of the child.

Note that any CHILD can be left at a hospital. No age limit. In other words, the Nebraska legislature just legalized child abandonment as long as it's done "properly."

Wanna test-drive your kid? Move to Nebraska! Terrible 2s? No problemo! How about that mouthy 13-year old son? Cheaper than Ritalin.

LB157 is the late Dr. Pierce's fantasy of flexibility" of choice, "non-bureaucratic placement" and safe havens at any age.* Appropriately, Nebraska is Dr. Pierce's home state. Lately, he's been thunking his shoe in heaven (think Maine!) , but I heard a little chortle, too.

More on Nebraska later.


*Due to time constraints, I have unable to find Bill's comment about edging up the age of SH kids, which he posted on alt.adoption. I'm still looking.

Friday, January 19, 2007

BASTARD NATION'S SUBMITTED TESTIMONY IN OPPOSITION TO NEBRASKA LB 6

NOTE: This was submitted in opposition to LB 6, but the same objections hold for LB 157 which eventually was passed after many revisions and compromises.

Bastard Nation: The Adoptee Rights Organization--the largest adoptee civil rights organization in North America-- opposes LB 6 which if enacted would permit parents to “legally” abandon infants 30 days old or less.

Because infants surrendered under LB 6 are expected to be placed for adoption, Bastard Nation's objections to LB 6 focus on how the law will effect negatively the civil rights of adoptees.

(1) LB 6 erodes adoptee civil rights by increasing the number of anonymous children available for adoption through unethical and unprofessional practices.
LB 6 establishes parallel child welfare systems, where one system opposes the long-standing principles of the other. Those long-standing principles are informed consent and a full record of identifying information and social and medical histories. LB 6 eliminates adoptees’ rights to identity by denying their access to original birth and heritage records. Safe Haven laws were enacted right after Oregon and Alabama restored adopted adults' right to their original birth records. That was no coincidence. The National Council for Adoption (NCFA), a trade organization of conservative adoption agencies dedicated to sealed and secret adoptions and opposed to adoptee identity rights have admitted before various state legislatures, that Safe Haven laws are the response to the growing and successful movement in the US to restore the civil right of identity to adoptees. NCFA claims that only through anonymous abandonment can courts maintain “parental privacy“--though adoption proceedings are already closed and confidential in every state.

LB 6 denies parents--particularly non-surrendering parents (usually the father) --their right to due process by eliminating their ability to locate the dependency proceeding to which they are a party. LB 6 contravenes the family reunification guidelines of the federal Adoption and Safe Families Act and parts of the federal Indian Child Welfare Act. LB 6 replaces professional best practice standards with unprofessional and unethical "non-bureaucratic placement" by letting parents abandon solely for convenience or out of ignorance. The law preys on parents who honestly believe they are surrendering their child for adoption instead of providing evidence to be used in a dependency hearing at which they have a right and duty to appear. The law encourages parents literally to default at their hearings. The supporters call that "proper" and "courageous."

(2) SB 6 disenfranchises natural parents, encourages unethical behavior, and hides crime.
There is no evidence that Safe Haven laws have decreased unsafe abandonment or saved lives. A 2005 survey of county coroners in California found that the number of newborns dying from abandonment and neglect since 2001 remained at 13-15 per year.

Save Havens are promoted as an easy solution for mothers so desperate that unless they can abandon their newborns anonymously the mothers will kill the children. State-written reports and news accounts tell a different story.The “Safely Surrendered and Abandoned Infants in Los Angeles County” ICAN report published in 2002 and updated in 2005, identified Safe Haven-protected parents who were interviewed as poor, overwhelmed, and ignorant of child welfare practice. Some parents appeared to be undocumented workers, leery of professional assistance.

News accounts throughout the country regularly tell us of clean, immaculately dressed newborns with stuffed animals, baby blankets, and notes to doctors, left at ER’s in no danger of neglect or death. Newspapers have also reported instances in which hospital officials, in conflict with established hospital programs that discourage incidents of “boarder baby abandonment” encourage identified, confined mothers to leave their newborns at the hospital when they are later discharged with no ethical parenting or child placement counseling to guide them.

Safe Haven laws are open to further abuses as shown by the Twyana Davis case in Ohio. Davis, an adult, conceived a child with her 12-year old cousin. Davis recklessly abandoned the newborn. After years of supporting Safe Haven laws , Davis admitted the father's identity and age. Last fall she was sentenced to 10-25 years in prison for rape. In April 2006, in Rochester, New York, Lamar Brown, 31, tried to drop off a newborn he claimed he found in a nearby park. When hospital personnel became suspicious and called police, Brown admitted that he had had sexual relations with the 13-year old mother 9 months earlier and had helped deliver the baby. He was charged with 2nd degree rape and endangering the welfare of a child. Safe Haven proponents would have Davis and Brown legally abandon these babies anonymously and then call them heroes. The government is essentially offering parents who have committed, or are contemplating, crimes a cover up.

Abuses are not the exception. In several cases the parent has communicated to the Safe Haven recipient that they were surrendering the child anonymously out of love or because they lacked resources. Those parents did not feel homicidal, but simply wanted a quick or secret adoption. Temporary and permanent surrender options have existed for decades and are used by thousands of new parents every year. We have welfare and other programs through children's services that new parents can use when they lack funds or support.

Unfortunately, Safe Haven proponents have convinced parents they have only two options: The Dumpster or the Safe Haven.. The responsible alternatives to baby dumping are not mentioned: counseling, public assistance, temporary surrender, permanent surrender for adoption, and family communication. That omission keeps new and potential parents ignorant of real solutions.As Bob Brandt, Executive Director of The Nebraska Children’s Home Society said in 2004 when a similar proposal to LB 6 was presented to the legislature, “Safe Haven laws are a way to circumvent adoption laws and have unintended consequences…I hope society doesn’t get to the point where they think abandonment of a child is a good thing. We just get the word out there that there is safe help We think we have laws that allow us to protect the babies.”


Finally, Nebraska law does not need fixed.
There is no epidemic of newborn abandonments and neonaticides in the state. Since 1996, 3 discarded newborns have been found alive and 1 found dead from unknown causes.SB 6 trivializes baby abandonment by presenting it as just another consumer choice. No blame. No shame. No names.Furthermore, by encouraging identity erasure, parental ignorance, irresponsibility, and secrecy, and by refuting the due process rights of parents, LB 6 endangers the integrity and safety of all families in the State of Nebraska--not just those at risk for unsafe abandonment. No law is valid because it might "save a life." Otherwise, we would not have our Bill of Rights. We do not let the police pull drivers over randomly and give them Breathalyzer tests because "it might save a life." We do not outlaw guns because “it might save a life." The state should not help parents hide their own children’s identities and histories because “it might save a life.” It should not help parents hide children from each other because “it might save a life.”

Protect Nebraska families! Vote Do Not Pass on LB 6.

Marley Elizabeth Greiner
Executive Chair
Bastard Nation: The Adpotee Rights Organization