Sunday, October 19, 2008

The Michigan dumped kid was an adoptee, NE ‘return to sender’ dumps him back into the MI System

No blogger could begin to keep up with the mess Nebraska legislators have made. Instead, this post will focus on some of the raw sources dealing with the recent dumps. I’ll slide in a little commentary, but mainly I urge readers to go look at the articles and the videos in my links, they spell out a long sad story of failure. But then when it comes to the dump laws there’s rarely any good news, for the kids anyway.

Here is an Omaha World-Herald round up of many of the recent stories they’ve done relating to the dumps and the aftermath. Lots of links, well worth the read.

As but one example, see their Oct 9th story, Grandmother: Help, not haven, sought for boy which details how one of the kids abandoned was supposedly never intended to be such:

An Omaha grandmother says she wanted to hospitalize her suicidal 12-year-old grandson — not use the safe haven law — when she asked the boy’s aunt Sunday to take him to Immanuel Medical Center.

But instead of receiving help, the boy was placed in a foster home. He is scheduled to move to a group home this weekend.

And the grandmother has been ordered to show up in court next Wednesday for reasons she says she doesn’t understand.

That her grandson is considered a safe haven case is a “misunderstanding,” the woman said.

Regardless of the intent behind each and every single dump, one thing remains perfectly clear, Nebraska’s law is for the first time putting America’s catastrophically broken child welfare system on display while simultaneously putting a spotlight on many of the problems inherent to the legalized child abandonment laws. Additionally, due to the age problems unique to Nebraska’s law, this is all playing out upon kids old enough to remember every sorry detail of it.

But EVEN IF THEY COULDN’T, THE DAMAGE ABANDONMENT DOES TO KIDS, THE KNOWLEDGE THAT THEY WERE ABANDONED, AND THAT THE STATE ACTIVELY ENCOURAGED THEIR ABANDONMENT is still a lifelong betrayal. Child abandonment produces scars time doesn’t heal.

The dump laws make a mockery of any notion of child welfare best practices. Nebraska is merely the most visible and extreme example thereof. By creating the non-anonymous and aged-up version of the laws Nebraska put the full ugliness of the dump laws on international display.

Now that we begin to see the full horror of these legal atrocities there’s only one thing left to do, REPEAL them.

One by one, state after state, pull these abominations back out of the code.

Which brings us to the Michigan boy dumped by his mother in Nebraska, make that adoptive mother, because you see, he was an adoptee.

The Michigan to Nebraska dump was not only a ‘teach you a lesson’ dump, it was also a ‘returns department’ dump. An adopted kid, no longer wanted by his adopters.

Click to Enlarge

Teri, left, and Terrence Martin of Southfield, Mich., the adoptive parents of a 13-year-old boy abandoned in Nebraska under that state’s safe haven law.

(AP Photo/Paul Sancya)

I’m not going to get into every twist and turn of the Mess from Michigan, but I’ll provide a few links worth looking through.

October 13th-

Video from CBS 3 in Omaha (see * below)- Michigan Mom Drops off Son Under Safe Haven. While local news stations are calling it “safe haven crisis” Nebraska politicians still aren’t getting the message.

The video piece includes parts of an interview with State Sen. Brad Ashford:

We passed the law to protect Nebraska children. We didn’t pass the law to protect children from other states.

and

I don’t think it’s a crisis. I, again, it’s not a bad thing that children are being protected.

While Sen. Ashford may personally characterize being abandoned in the Nebraska’s ‘returns department’ as “being protected” there are at this point a number of kids who have actually been through the process who may have a bone to pick with him. Kids like this pregnant 14 year-old girl abandoned through the Nebraska system who had this to say about being dumped:

“I don’t want anything to happen to kids like it happened to me, …”

(She has since been returned to her home.)

October 14th-

Let’s start back here with New Details On Safe Haven Child From Michigan. Douglas County Attorney Don Kleine,

… also says the state of Nebraska is not going to take in children from all over the country. He plans to work with child protective services in Michigan to send this kid back, while at the same time making sure the child is in good hands.

(Never mind the fact that the Nebraska law says nothing about ‘no out of state dumps allowed!’ The way the law is written it’s a free for all, anyone with physical custody can dump a kid, be that domestic or even international!)

The AP did a piece, the morning of the 14th, (this by way of WXYZ in Detroit, Michigan) Local Mom Abandons Teen in Nebraska. (Also see related video on upper right hand corner.) Once again, we see a kid not in any immediate danger-

There was no sign the boy was in immediate danger before he was abandoned early Monday, but an investigation into the boy’s situation was still continuing, Landry said.

A second piece, also from WXYZ, Michigan Mom Who Abandoned Son Identified.

KETV- Court Docs Reveal Story Behind Latest Safe Haven Case This piece goes into just a bit more detail about the ‘teach ‘em a lesson’ aspect of this dump and makes clear, the adoptive mother never intended to actually lose custody of him:

Martin told workers she would come back to get her son and now her son would know she wasn’t kidding.

As to the Judge’s comments in this piece, I don’t think loss family bonds should ever be the ‘cost’ of gaining access to support systems or mental health care. Everything he discusses in this piece can be done WITHOUT the state legalizing child abandonment.

October 15th-

Omaha World Herald-

Michigan boy left at Omaha hospital to stay in Nebraska - for now

and Michigan mother may have used safe haven law as lesson which includes:

“She told hospital staff that since local police were included she would just come back to get (her son), since now he would realize she wasn’t kidding anymore,” the affidavit says.

Nebraska Department of Health and Human Services officials confirmed that the mother had second thoughts about leaving her son. But once a child is left under the law and the state has taken custody, parents or guardians lose their right to make decisions about what happens to the child.

WXYZ, Michigan Mom who Abandoned Son Identified also see video.

October 16th-

KCBY (Oregon), Parents of Mich. boy left in Neb. lose custody.

Three Faux/Fox Detroit links, the first two are AP stories;

Court: Mom Who Abandoned Boy Can’t See Other Kids,

Official: Mich. Mom Neglected Boy She Left in Neb.,

and Children Taken from Mother Who Abandoned Son.

According to the video segment, on the third piece, the adopters were receiving (federal) adoption subsidies for the two kids to the tune of $900 a month. The adopters had apparently “tried for years” to get rid of their two adopted kids.

Note that once again, the adoption subsidies mess that I’ve already blogged about in relation to the dump laws is right in the middle of all this.

Also see, Michigan Prosecutors Don’t Want Mom to Use Nebraska Safe Haven Again

The grandmother said good-bye to the boy before his mother drove to Omaha. She left him Monday morning at the hospital with a packed suitcase and a ten dollar bill. Grandmother says, “She was taking him to a boys’ home that’s what she said a place to take boys with problems.” the grandmother says the boy’s been trouble and they tried to get help for years.

But the Michigan prosecutor found a report from 1999 accusing the mother of burning the boy with a curling iron. For some unknown reason, the state dropped the investigation.

This last bit is particularly important, it implies Michigan dropped the ball long before the dump in Nebraska. Which is to say, this may very well have been an abandonment that never would have happened had there been intervention back at the point where the adopted kid was accused of being burned by his adoptive mother.

All of which points back at the larger problems involved in follow up post placement for adoptees and how over and over again, these kids are simply left to suffer while the adopters collect the federal checks.

Oct 17th

AP by way of CNN- Parents who left teen under safe haven law lose custody

The report said Terri Martin told Nebraska officials that she took the boy there to “scare him,” yet she denied incidents of aggression.

It also said state records showed evidence that neither parent wanted the 13-year-old, who was adopted along with his 10-year-old brother.

AP by way of Faux/Fox Detroit, Court Grants State Temporary Custody of 4 Children

The report also cited a history of referrals to child-welfare officials because of reports of injuries to the teen. Carley is seeking to eliminate the Martins’ parental rights over the 13-year-old. The next court hearing is Nov. 7.

“We think there are some possibilities they could learn to parent the other three safely,” Carley said.

Nebraska has agreed to drop jurisdiction over the teen and let Michigan help him.

Yeah, that would be the Michigan child-welfare system that has apparently already failed him spectacularly. But right back in he goes, ’cause Nebraska doesn’t want him either. This is a kid who has been abandoned not merely by his adopters, but by every state tasked with helping him.

If there was an ongoing history of injuries to the kid, I ask again, what was the deal on his placement? If the adopters were receiving subsidies that would usually mean they took in an older child or sibling group or ’special needs’ kid out of the foster care system. If he was interacting with the system repeatedly due to injuries and burns, who was the person or agency responsible for keeping him with this set of adopters?

Just dumping the kid back into the broken Michigan system ‘disapears’ him right back in.

If Nebraska was at all serious about ’saving’ kids, they might not be so quick to hand over jurisdiction.

But that’s not what Nebraska’s dump law is about. Clearly.

Getting him and his siblings away from the adopters is one thing, getting him away from the system that sent him right back to those adopters after injuries and burns is apparently quite another.

Be sure to see the video piece related to this link, as there are many new details in it, including allegations of the boy having endured sexual abuse.

More video, (again see below *) New Details in Michigan Safe Haven Case, The piece details the adopters charged in Michigan with abuse and neglect.

They claim the boy was abandoned in Nebraska after being advised to do so by a therapist and that his adopters…

…tried to find him a new home again and again.

So once again we have a ‘therapist’ whatever that might mean and whatever qualifications that might entail, telling the guardians to use the dump law.

State Sen. Stuthman (the longtime supporter and sponsor of the Nebraska dump law) wants her prosecuted in Michigan to send a message to the rest of the country.

The ‘message’ of course being that no matter how broadly the Nebraska law was written, everyone involved is now shitting bricks at the prospect of hoards of dumpers crossing state lines to bring their potential dumplings to Nebraska. Gee, usually that’s the kind of thing one might want to think about BEFORE such gets signed into law.

So now we’ve got legalized child abandonment/ ’safe haven’ advocates like State Senator Stuthman trying to close the barn door long after the fact.

It’s important to keep in mind that Sen. Stuthman and other such advocates are precisely who and what got Nebraska into this mess in the first place, all based upon their blind insistence that Nebraska ‘needed’ such a law.

Hint, no kid ever NEEDS to be abandoned.

Also note,

… the court papers outline how the family tried to give back the troubled boy since he was four even going to the birthmother.

This is interesting as it means the adopters had some form of access to the original mother.

(Nebraska) DHHS News Release Safe Haven Youth Returns to Michigan

Also importantly, NPR has a five minute All Things Considered piece, Neb. Safe Haven Law Draws More Than Infants, along with links to past stories about the Nebraska disaster.

It goes into detail about some of the kids themselves reactions to being dumped, describing the extreme duress this law is putting some of the kids through.

October 18th-

Omaha World-Herald, Teen to go home, but state will have custody

Oakland County, Mich., prosecutors are seeking temporary custody of four of the 13-year-old’s siblings still living at home. Deb Carley, the county prosecutor, said an investigation found that the parents had neglected all their children.

Well, mission accomplished, eh?

Right back into the system that didn’t think his adopters were bad enough to warrant losing him prior to the dump.

But Nebraska understands the precedent that would be set by accepting even one out of state dump, so ‘what best for the kid’ be damned. Quick! Get ‘em on a plane!

I can’t wait to see what his next digs are going to be like, foster care? Group home? Think the siblings will get to stay together?

Yeah, well, somehow I doubt wherever Michigan decides to park him until he ages out will be making CNN anytime soon.

This boy is dumped alright.

Nebraska’s washed its hands of him and the odds of him finding ‘a loving adoptive home’ back in Michigan aren’t looking so hot.

* FINALLY-

I’m having some difficulty linking the individual videos, but you can use the search feature on the homepage of CBS 3 news in Omaha to pull up the video links, just search by the video segment names:

Michigan Mom Drops off Son Under Safe Haven 10/13/08 6:44pm

Michigan Boy Latest Safe Haven Drop-Off 10/13/08 11:48pm

Safe Haven Case in Michigan Reveals Child in Trouble 10/14/08 11:44pm

New Details in Michigan Safe Haven Case 10/17/08 6:55pm

***

I suppose the next question should be how many more kids, unwanted, adopted, or otherwise are going to be taken on 12 hour or more car rides to be dumped by those who have physical custody of them?

If Nebraska legislators think this is “not a crisis” perhaps that has more to do with it not being a crisis for them.

For the kids, they can’t wait until January for the Nebraska legislature to step up and begin to tackle (or perhaps if they have the courage, ‘undo’ to the extent they can going forward) the crisis they created.

They can’t wait while legislators hem and haw and contemplate the possibilities.

They need an end to legalized abandonments.

And they need it now.

To date 21 kids have undergone some form of abandonment in Nebraska, even if NE DHHS only formally counts 18 of them (link opens a PDF), (see my earlier blogging on the numbers game being played here.) That’s 21 kids who would not have had to endure the turmoil of being abandoned but for the short sighted and ill-advised actions of the Nebraska legislature.

At what point do they finally recognize their little social experiment is causing harm to the kids?

What will it take before legislators finally show some spine and put an end to the mess they’ve created?

Legalized child abandonment laws need to be REPEALED. Period. No state should ever be in the business of actively encouraging child abandonment.

The kids can’t wait another day, …another hour, …another minute.

Only Nebraska legislators hold the power to put a stop to this, it’s long past time they realized their mistake and worked to prevent further damage.

As for the 21 kids already enduring the effects of this legislation, they’ll be living with it the rest of their lives.

For each and every one of them, trust me on this, I think they’d be the first to tell you, it was absolutely a point of crisis.

A crisis they will be enduring the consequences of from now on.

Friday, October 17, 2008

The Staton abandonment and the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA)

Before even starting to write about this topic, keep in mind the disclaimer I’ve placed upon earlier writings I’ve done in relation to First Nations peoples and adoption:

To start from a personal perspective, I’m just a Bastard, a politically active adoptee.

Being legally prohibited from attaining my State sealed records, I have no idea what heritage cultural or genetic my biological family might contain, other than a quick glance in a mirror appears to indicate pretty clearly a hefty chunk of what would generally be termed “white” by sociological definition. The family history of those who adopted me has interwoven at times with First Nations peoples on both the American and Canadian sides of the border.

While my interest in this subject, yes at times does relate to aspects of ‘familial’ history, my primary interest in such is historical and political, speaking from both a Bastard perspective, as one who opposes forms and tactics of colonialism (religious, political, etc), and as one who supports indigenous peoples’ autonomy and demands for redress.

***

staton-photo.jpg

Ironically, the Indian Child Welfare Act, or ICWA in relation to the dump laws was precisely what I had been intending to blog about, but hadn’t had the time to get to. Well sure enough, in Nebraska, we appear to have the first case(?) of an ICWA claim in the wake of a “safe haven” legalized abandonment.

…Channel 6 News found out Wednesday the Cherokee Nation based in Oregon may have a legal claim to raise the Staton kids because they are part Native American.

(Also be sure to see the video related to the piece.)

Why haven’t we had an ICWA dump related claim before now? Perhaps because in most states abandoners are anonymous and the abandoned kids are not old enough to answer questions relating to their genealogy.

(Again, ‘aging down’ will not ’solve’ these problems. Changing Nebraska’s dump law to apply only to infants would only create a new state-created ‘pocket’ in which to hide crucial information such as a child’s genealogical background, information vital to an ICWA claim. Adoptees in closed adoptions, such as myself actually know a great deal about that, as we have no means by which to determine any First Nations ancestry we may or may not have.)

While I have been working on a longer post about the nine kids Gary Staton abandoned back on September 24th, and the aftermath of that abandonment;

  • how the kids have ended up at the heart of legal battles,
  • having to make difficult choices between remaining with their friends at their school, or staying as a family unit with the other kids,
  • how it has played out across multiple states,
  • and how it has played out between family members and Nebraska Health and Human Services,

but for the moment I’m going to set that saga aside to focus solely on the ICWA angle.

Bastard Nation, The Adoptee Rights Organization warned about how the dump laws circumvent ICWA early on, pointing out that such laws:

Contravene sections of the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) which give tribes first custody rights in cases of child relinquishment.

Bastard Nation has brought the issue up many times in testimony trying to stop the dump laws. State after state, in enacting their dump laws have disregarded their obligations under ICWA.

I have also pointed out that dump laws short circuit ICWA claims in my own previous blogging. (While this particular post I’ve linked is primarily relating to Canadian First Nations children, some of whom were later adopted by American couples, it’s an important read as backgrounder and context to the history of how First Nations children have been actively resettled into white families. Dump laws must be understood within the broader context of forcible child removal as a means by which to cut off Tribes’ futures.) Bastardette has also pointed out the ICWA violation in relation to Nebraska’s dump law.

As an aside, Shea Grimm in her search series has also written about ICWA’s pertinence to sealed records adoptees’ attempts to regain access to their own records, see her section Using The Indian Child Welfare Act in a petition. Unfortunately this often ends up in the catch-22 of having to first know about your Native ancestry to to gain the information relating to your Native ancestry. But then, there’s very little about adoption that is logical and straightforward.

The First Nations Orphan Association is an important voice relating to issues of First Nations kids and adoption . Again, bear in mind such adoptions were often done within a context of non-consentuality. Large numbers of Native children were forcibly removed for adoption. ICWA was in part a response to those crimes committed. But now with the baby Moses laws/”Safe Haven” laws/baby dump laws, a new means of bypassing ICWA has been constructed, once again undermining Tribal rights.

The legalized abandonment laws continue that history of permanently removing children from their Tribal or genealogical heritage, far more so for the infant dumps than Nebraska’s older child dumps, as at least these older kids have perhaps some knowledge of their heritage. The dump laws provide an adoption intake path, wherein certainly for infants, questions of Tribal legal claims are never even raised, doing so in flagrant violation of the Indian Child Welfare Act.

Tribes are not just ‘another player’ in the legal tug of war over kids, they are sovereign Nations. Cutting them out of the equation via the legalized abandonment laws is nothing more than once again creating a new way to circumvent their means to protect children’s identities and Tribal futures.

You want a four letter reason why legalized child abandonment laws must be REPEALED? ICWA.

Infant and anonymous dump laws are the bypass on ICWA.

Older child abandonments will only face ICWA challenges when Tribes have the resources and access to information to raise the claims, wrongly placing the burden of raising the claim on Tribes, rather than on the States who have obligations under ICWA.

Tinkering with age limits and other such details of these laws is not going to begin to deal with the fundamental flaws inherent to all dump laws.

Full REPEAL is the only answer.

Thursday, October 16, 2008

DESPERATE PARENTS DROP OFF G.W. BUSH AT NEBRASKA HOSPITAL: MORE POLITICIANS TO COME?

This just in!

Citing Nebraska's Safe Haven Law to take in unruly children, The Former President and First Lady, dropped off the current President, George W., hoping the action would finally give the nation some peace during the declining days of his Presidency...

"Signing those final abandonment papers was really hard," W's Mom said, "but we were at our wits end. His infantile, incorrigible behavior for the past 7 plus years almost broke his father's heart. Thank God for Nebraska!. It will really serve as "the last safe haven for the Country!"


continued here

OK. As opposed as I am to any "safe haven" law, I'll make an exception in this case. Mr. Bush's parents have obviously done the right thing for themselves and the country. Now if only Roberta McCain could come to the same conclusion. If it saves just one......

The Michigan Mom already under investigation and the failures of baby-dumps

We begin with the mother (along with an aunt and grandmother) who drove from Michigan to Nebraska to dump her son,

New twist in abandonment of 13-year-old in Nebraska/Prosecutor’s office files a neglect petition against Southfield family

turns out she was ALREADY under investigation back in Michigan prior to the abandonment.

The Oakland County Prosecutor’s Office has filed a neglect petition against the Southfield family of the 13-year-old boy whose mother drove to Nebraska to abandon him under that state’s expansive and controversial safe haven law.

The filing was not released for public review before Oakland County Circuit Court closed for the day, but a hearing was scheduled for 2:30 p.m. today, deputy court administrator Lisa Langton said.

While the mother is protected by Nebraska law, she could face charges in Michigan, where she and her husband have four other children. And local authorities and court records say the family already was being investigated before the teen was taken to Nebraska.

The case also is causing a rift between social services and law enforcement.

Southfield Police Chief Joseph Thomas Jr. said he and county Prosecutor David Gorcyca were upset that the Michigan Department of Human Services did not involve them immediately in a case where a child was taken across state lines.

She abandoned the boy at Omaha’s Creighton University Medical Center with luggage, extra clothes and $10.

Sadder still, this was a apparently another ‘teach ‘em a lesson’ dump. Not dissimilar to how parents have used the threat of and reality of juvenile hall in the past (see Mary E. Odem’s book “Delinquent Daughters: Protecting and Policing Adolescent Female Sexuality in the United States, 1885-1920″ for an excellent examination of how “delinquency” has historically been used against kids)

The boy told police his mother was stressed out and couldn’t deal with him anymore. He also she was trying to teach him a lesson. She has expressed remorse to Nebraska officials.

Apparently after driving 12 hours and legally abandoning her son to ‘teach him a lesson’ she is now sorry for having done so. Lovely.

This goes to the core of any legalized child abandonment law, how easy it becomes for events to unfurl rapidly. The kid will be dealing with such for the rest of his life, but for the adults involved, parents, legislators etc, it’s all about making it quick and easy.

And once again, we have private agencies in the midst of all of it:

As a student in Southfield Public Schools, the teen is “not a student with a bad profile,” and wasn’t known to be having difficulties according to Ken Siver, deputy superintendent.

But the family has files with both social services and law enforcement in Wayne and Oakland counties.

According to court records, in 2003, a neglect petition filed in Wayne County on behalf of the boy was denied. He also was prescribed mental health services for a delinquency charge in 2007.

In Southfield, both he and a sibling have open delinquency files, Thomas said.

A private agency tasked with placing the 13-year-old with relatives during a complaint “expressed concern about this child’s safety and remaining in the family in any way,” said Janet Snyder, executive director for Michigan Federation for Children and Families, a child-serving agency advocacy group.

Undoubtedly we will be hearing much much more about this case.

It’s important to keep in mind, though that the only reason we know that the mother was under investigation back in Michigan is because Nebraska’s dump law, unlike many states, does not have anonymous abandoners, and the that in Nebraska, unlike any other state, the dumped kid is old enough to speak for himself.

Had this happened in another state, with anonymous abandoners and a baby being dumped, no questions would be asked, the baby would simply enter the adoption stream and the dumper would go on about their life.

Which is to say baby-dumps can be used to cover all kinds of things.

‘Aging down’ a legalized child abandonment law is no solution. ‘Aging down’ merely increases the number of things that can be hidden under a dump law.

***

In a separate second story we learn of an Iowa woman who has scheduled a protest in Nebraska today:

An Iowa woman angry about Nebraska’s safe haven law is staging a protest at Creighton University in Omaha.

Judi Wheeldon of Council Bluffs, Iowa, said she hopes the protest, scheduled for 5 p.m. today, will help convince state lawmakers to convene and put an age limit in the law before the regular legislative session starts in January.

(Also see Lawmakers Not Ready For Special Session)

Iowa, of course has a baby-dump law. Targeting Creighton, which is merely a state designated intake center for the dumped kids is ultimately pretty pointless. It’s Nebraska lawmakers, not hospitals who decide the fate of this disastrous law.

If all Ms. Wheeldon is calling for is the aged down version, then the effect is that of calling for another shade of lipstick on the same old pig. Not calling for a fundamental change in the law, instead, merely a tweeking to make Nebraska’s look more like Iowa’s.

As I’ve said in all these posts about the Nebraska mess, the only real solution is a full REPEAL of the dumps laws.

Anything less just means a continuation of the current status quo, that of state’s continuing their sad and shameful course of action, encouraging child abandonment.

Monday, October 13, 2008

ANOTHER OUT-OF-STATE DUMPSTER DIVE

This just in.

The Detroit News reports that early this morning a 13-year old boy from Michigan was abandoned at a Nebraska hospital. The boy and his parent flew to Omaha for the drop-off. No details have been released other than the boy has been placed in an emergency shelter.

In the meantime, Arnie Struthman the sponsor of the state's safe haven law says he opposes the call for a special session of the legislature to revisit the law. According to him, Boys Town and the Untied Way can address issues so parents don't have to abandon children.

Later today I will post on this entry an updated list of dumpees, attempted dumpees, and any updates on this breaking story.

Drivin’ all night to dump a kid, Michigan Teen dumped

Where your children can become memories!

or is that

Making your children memories since July 2008!

***

Fly by dumping, flying the child abandonment skies.

Yup, welcome to the daily doom that is Nebraska’s legalized child abandonment law.

The Detroit (Michigan) News reports this morning on a Michigan parent who flew into Nebraska to legally abandon their 13 year old son.

After all what’s the cost of a plane ticket when compared with the looming prospect of college tuition?

KETV is now reporting the mother drove 12 hours in from Detroit:

At 3 p.m. on Monday, those officials said the mother was still in Omaha.

Todd Landry, director of the Division of Children and Family Services, said the department is working with Michigan officials and the Douglas County attorney’s office to resolve the situation.

The department has also been in contact with the boy’s family since the child was dropped off.Officials are trying to learn more about the circumstances of the latest case, but say the Columbus Day holiday is slowing the investigation.But officials reported that the boy was in no immediate danger and was not exhibiting any violent behavior.

Regardless of whether by air or by land, this is the second reported case of a cross state lines legalized abandonment resulting in a kid being abandoned in Nebraska. (The first, from Iowa is now back home in Iowa, “reunited” with her family, in no small part after Nebraska tried to raise the possibility of the parents being prosecuted in Iowa.)

At 6pm, an AP story just hit, containing a few more details:

The boy has been placed in an emergency shelter. Landry said the family doesn’t appear to have ties to Nebraska and he wasn’t sure if the family had sought help in Michigan first.

State officials have met with the boy’s mother, Landry said but wouldn’t immediately address her reasons for leaving her son. He said he believed the boy’s parents were married but wasn’t sure if the father agreed to the decision.

The article also reminds potential dumping parents that there are no guarantees they’ll be able to get their child back, should they want the kid back:

State officials have said parents and caregivers need to understand there is no guarantee an abandoned child could be returned to them if they change their minds. The have encouraged parents to seek other resources before resorting to abandonment.

Both the KETV and AP stories are reporting that per the Nebraska intake process, the boy was placed in an “emergency shelter.”

While I am unable to confirm this means this particular boy ended up at Project Harmony, based on previous statements (see this link for “Kids who are dropped off are brought to an organization called Project Harmony for evaluation,”) it’s a reasonable guess. Project Harmony runs a version of an “emergency shelter,” primarily for kids who have been sexually abused and has been woven into the Nebraska legalized child dumping intake process.

I wrote a post recently dealing with this outsourcing and some of the issued raised by such entitled Nebraska Dump Law, just how deep does this rabbit hole go?

At the tail end of the AP piece, Nebraska’s governor continues to push for a dump law 2.0 aimed at infants, (who due to the age issue, would be less likely to go on the evening news and be able to tell lawmakers and the world from first hand experience how much being dumped sucks.)

Gov. Dave Heineman has been reluctant to call a rare special session.

Landry declined to comment on whether a special session was needed, but he did say Monday that a new law is needed to specifically address infants in danger. Two children coming from out of state is clear evidence changes are needed, he said.

“We need to get back to the intent of the law,” he said. “The intent of the law was always the protection of newborns in immediate danger of being harmed.”

My advice to the Nebraska Governor is to pick on someone his own size.

Or at bare minimum someone old enough to be able to fight back/ able to articulate the damage legalized child abandonment laws do. Subjecting infants, those societally least able to speak out on behalf their own interests, to these laws just means waiting a few more years before being able to hear the first of the dumped infants tell you that child abandonment is not good policy.

No doubt, not all the kids dumped will despise them, but to use “safe haven” advocates rhetoric and twist it back against them, If it harms “just one”…!

Fantasies of infants abandoned and up for adoption resale aside, back in the real world, Nebraska continues to receive teens and older children, not a newborn among ‘em. Older kids on the resale market don’t move very well. Maybe that’s why Nebraska is considering hitting up guardian dumpers from child support to pay for ‘em.

None-the-less, the more people hear about this law is apparently the greater the number of parents willing to jump in the car and drive 12 hours to be rid of a kid.

We’re up to 21 attempted abandonments now. 21 kids who had it not been for the irresponsible actions of Nebraska state lawmakers would not have been legally abandoned, or abandonment attempts.

For every “baby safe haven” advocate who has ever whined, despairing of how they think their laws simply needed more publicity or a publicity budget, we now have one hell of a case study of what happens once the word gets out that the state will take kids off your hands.

These days, thanks to headlines around the globe and the TV 24 hour news cycle desperate for something to fill that space between the commercials, now unless you’ve been living under a rock plenty of people now think they know at least something about the Nebraska scheme and are happy to fill the blogosphere with their opinions of how “it’s a good law, just being ‘misused’”. However, most of the people spouting off about these legalized child abandonment laws have not passed through any portion of the child welfare or adoption systems. Bastardette, who is also doing coverage on this latest Nebraska dump and I have.

Meanwhile in the American psyche, “NEBRASKA” has taken the place of the proverbial bogeyman under the bed for some kids (note that the kids mentioned on the other end of this particular link have are already hip deep in quack-therapy RAD-land.) They fear they too, will face being ‘NEBRASKA-ED!” (Yup, it’s now a verb.)

Kids everywhere, living in fear, “Behave, or I’ll take you to Nebraska!”

Congratulations Nebraska legislators, you’ve made your state synonymous with state encouraged child abandonment in the national consciousness.

Puts a whole new twist on that ‘we adopted you, and you keep this up young lady, we can unadopt you too!’ (Yes we have seen at least one adoptee dumped into the ‘returns’ department.)

Nebraska legislators nervously eyeing the prospect of hordes of out of state teens being dumped into their already overburdened and underfunded child welfare system are hastily attempting to erect legislative walls trying to keep out of state dumpers out:

State Sen. Mike Flood, speaker of the Legislature, said that when the law is revised, he would like to see it pertain only to Nebraska residents, although he didn’t say how that might be accomplished.

Nebraska not being an anonymous dumper state can at least in theory, determine the point of origin of those bringing the kids to be dumped.

(Anonymous dumper states, of course mean in some cases anyone can bring a kid. One has to wonder whether international child dumping has ALREADY taken place, but due to the broadly written states laws we have no way of knowing. )

My ‘adopted’ home state of Maryland really takes the cake on the baby-dumps though, allowing any mother or anyone with the permission of the mother to leave any newborn 3 days old or less with ANYONE, ANYWHERE so long as the recipient is a “responsible adult”. The recipient then is supposed to take the newborn to a hospital. (see this link to a Child Welfare Information Gateway PDF document, search on “Cts & Jud Pro § 5-641″) Which is to say you gotta watch your back here in Maryland, after all, anyone could hand you a baby at any time.

Back in Nebraska, the ‘brain trust’ who brought us this day by day mounting dumped kid casualty count continue to blather the proverbial, ‘move along, move along, nothing to see here, we’ll get to it, nothing to worry about… .”

Nope, the current state of affairs, the rising toll of legally abandoned kids is apparently just fine by Nebraska State Senator Arnie Stuthman, of Platte Center. Stuthman opposes calling a special session saying:

agencies and organizations such as Boys Town and United Way can make headway in addressing the issues of families so they do not feel they have to abandon children.

Perhaps Sen. Stuthman would care to take that up with the the 13 year-old girl who was abandoned under Nebraska’s catastrophic legalized abandonment law back on September 20th. She had ALREADY been at Boys Town until she was removed by her great aunt the beginning of the summer. She had been removed due to her great aunt’s concerns about potential over medication during her time at Boys Town:

A 13-year-old girl who’d been diagnosed with bipolar disorder, fetal alcohol syndrome, and severe behavioral problems. She was prone to fly into rages and and had been living at Boys Town until her great aunt removed her at the beginning of the summer, concerned that the girl was being medicated too heavily.

After the girl smeared her menstrual blood on the walls of her house, the “aunt called agencies for help but said she could not find a program,” the World-Herald reports. When the girl tried to jump out of a moving car, her great aunt took her to a hospital and asked for help.

“I can’t do nothing for her anymore. It’s too dangerous,” she told the Omaha newspaper.

So Sen. Stuthman’s ‘answer’ is to send her right back into the situation she just came out of.

In other words his answer is no answer, how perfectly circular.

I’ve said from the beginning, we are looking at decades worth of budget slashing and privatization of services, the state abdicating its duty to its citizens, seeing “faith-based” institutions as solution structures. The legalized child abandonment laws are just revealing the already pre-existing rot and failures of precisely those ‘public/private partnership’ arrangements. Kids are falling through those gaps.

Rather than attempting to readjust the shade of lipstick on the pig to a colour more soothing, the only real answer at this point is to innovate.

It’s past time Nebraska did a system-wide assessment, and began to build genuine support structures offering real support to kids and families. Stop outsourcing, stop privatizing, stop assuming someone else can take care of it.

‘Can’t someone else do it?’ may make for a great campaign slogan on the Simpsons, but most Americans expect more of real politicians than of their cartoon counterparts. (Further, real life politicians might do well to remember how that particular Simpsons episode ends!)

Before that assessment process begins, the immediate needs of kids need to come first. The Nebraska legislators have created a crisis, they need to do the only thing that is going actually help these kids instead of continuing the harm already inflicted on at least 21 kids so far, REPEAL the legalized abandonment law. Take the lead nationally, and realize that legalized child abandonment is not something any state should be encouraging.

Being the only state without a law encouraging abandonment is not something to be ashamed of, it would be something to be proud of. Nebraska could, if legislators had the will, return Nebraska to its former place of honour, that of being a state that does not encourage child abandonment.

Encouraging legalized child abandonment is nothing less than the state putting its hands in its pockets, shrugging its shoulders, and mumbling, “we got nothing”, then passing the kids off to whichever ’someone else’ happens to be handy, (usually along with a nice big fat check).

Kids deserve better.

The Nebraska legislature’s mishandling of child welfare in this manner is unconscionable. These kids are going to have to live with their (legislators) mistakes for a lifetime.

End child legalized abandonment now.

REPEAL the legalized abandonment law.

(Quick, before the next flight lands.)

Friday, October 10, 2008

Implications of the abandonment laws, adoption financial incentives, and language tangles

The financial landscape of adoption itself has changed greatly over the past 30 years here in the U.S.. It is important to study for example, what the implications of the new subsidies and tax breaks will be in relation to the legalized child abandonment laws.

Through those past few decades a number of initiatives both public and private have been created geared towards increasing the number of adoptions. While many were conceived of as a way to increase adoptions from foster care for example, the effects have often included private international adoptions as well. This is one of the core problems in adoption, that words like ‘adoption’ itself covers so much, allowing each individual to hear what they want to hear and assume what they want to assume about what they thought they just heard.

To one, upon hearing about an ‘adoption’ they may think of an 11 year old African American boy removed by the state from an abusive home situation, placed in foster care and now in need of permanency, stability and parents who won’t beat him. He is eventually adopted by relatives with state support as they would be unable to take him in otherwise. Had they not adopted him, he may well have remained in foster care bouncing house to house through the years until he aged out at 18.

To another, hearing the same word, ‘adoption’, they may think of a vanity adoption by a wealthy supermodel hoping for the tabloid publicity of childrearing without the downside of stretch marks. She flies off to another country to pick up her child, a photogenic “orphaned” girl amidst the flashing cameras of the paparazzi. Once she been adopted and brought back to the states, she is left to be raised by nannies while ‘mom’ jet sets internationally. When the media glare has waned, she adopts a second and hits the front pages again.

The bottom line is ‘adoption’ can mean both simultaneously.

(I haven’t even gotten into adoption as a means of movement growth, or for theological purposes, both of which play very central roles in not only a percentage of American adoptions, but also is a major factor in some of the recent adoption related legislation.)

Unfortunately, as government and industry has grappled with adoption, they have in many cases made assumptions about adoption as it being a ‘universal good’ and ‘universally child-centric’ even when provably, in at least some cases, far from an act by which parents are there for children in need, it’s clear we are finding children adopted to fulfill adopters needs. While adoption subsides are predicated upon the idea of adoption as inherently an act of altruism, and a civic good to be publicly supported (financially and otherwise), that again, is based merely upon one set of assumptions about the role of adoption and its place in society.

So for starters, let’s get some very basic assumptions about definitions out of the way.

Let’s talk about foster care. People hear the words and often assume you’re discussing an older child who is spending long periods of time in foster care. While often true, you may also be discussing an infant kept in foster care very briefly, a month or less. People also assume ‘adopting out of foster care’ is always being done by a family unrelated to the foster care, while in practice, you often have foster parents adopting the kids, or infants they foster. So to turn the initial assumption on its head, you may have a child just a few days old placed with a foster family, who perhaps a year or two down the line adopt the toddler. The kid has been with them almost from the beginning, but this still qualifies as a foster adoption.

Next, let’s discuss “special needs” kids. People hear “special needs” and immediately jump to the (incorrect) conclusion that one must be speaking of ‘a black kid’ or a child with severe medical challenges. Again, while some certainly are, the “special needs” classification covers many more kids. Some of the other criteria include membership in a minority group, medical conditions or handicaps (physical, emotional, mental), being part of a sibling group, or older than 5 years old, or (notably, in relation to the dump laws) abandoned with custody relinquished to the state. The precise definitions vary state to state (and the District, Washington D.C.).

Finally, let me just make brief mention of HWIs, or “Healthy White Infants”. These are the kids most sought after in the adoption marketplace. As they can be difficult to come by, they tend to pull top dollar.

All three of these must be kept in mind as we go into just a very brief overview of some of the financial landscape of adoption today.

Adoption now exists amidst a web of forms of financial assistance, both public and private. While there are some differences based on whether the adoption is international or domestic, and there has been some scaling of benefits tied to family income, there are now a number of programs offering financial incentives as a means to encourage adoptions.

One of the most important pieces of the financial picture is the Federal Adoption Tax Credit. Some agencies advocate taking out a short term adoption loan to cover the period between the adoption and when families receive the adoption tax credit itself. The tax credit can also be spread across multiple years.

There can be other forms of federal financial support offered to “special needs” or former foster kids through programs like Medicaid for medical assistance and access to social services as if the child were an AFDC recipient.

Fifteen states offer an additional state tax benefit (Arizona, California, Idaho, Iowa, Kansas, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Missouri, New Mexico, North Dakota, Oklahoma, Utah, West Virginia, and Wisconsin.) Many also offer additional grants and subsidies.

Even if the adoption has not been finalized, if the child has been placed with a family, they are still able to deduct the time the child is with them on their taxes as a dependent.

Federally, you also have the Child Tax Credit.

Beyond the tax incentives, there are also additional subsidies available to many families via the Federal Title IV-E program under the Social Security Act. The Title IV-E Adoption Assistance Program is for kids adopted from foster care and those deemed “special needs”. These monthly checks can continue until the adoptee is 18 or even 21.

(Recently, I blogged about the Renee Bowman case in Maryland and the $800 per child per month subsidy Bowman had been receiving, even as two of her three adopted children were dead, frozen in a block of ice. The third was being abused. None were apparently ever enrolled in Maryland public schools and to date, there has been no evidence the kids received any education at all. None the less, the checks kept coming as they were apparently not tied to actually proving the adoptees they were intended for the support of were still even alive.)

Both state and federal programs also have special one-time payments of non-recurring adoption expenses available for families adopting ’special needs’ kids. The special payments usually relate to the costs incurred in the course of the adoption itself.

Additionally, there are now numerous employers who offer their employees various forms of adoption assistance. Beyond family leave time, some workplaces offer matching funds or even outright financial assistance as part of their employee benefit packages. See the Dave Thomas foundation’s “Top 100 Adoption Friendly workplaces for 2008″ full list of America’s 2008 Top 100 for a sampling of what some workplaces offer to encourage their employees to adopt. (Dave Thomas, and the Dave Thomas foundation are yet another topic for another day. Don’t get me started… .)

An entire private industry has grown up around the financing of adoptions. Some portions of it are subsets of the banking industry, others are foundations or funds, some religiously motivated (adoption for movement growth or theological reasons.) Many offer low interest adoption loans.

Yes, you can even find places like the (evil) adoptiondotcom telling potential adopters they can put the kid on the their credit cards (suckers!) or better still,

If you can pay off the entire balance within the introductory period of a zero interest credit card, you can use this option free of interest.

While they advocate paying it off immediately, that’s hardly how most Americans relate to the plastic in their pockets. Care to contemplate the interest rates on that one? (Just what is the APR on little Suzy, anyway?)

Then there are those who, for example view “special needs” kids as their christian mission field , or “unreached people group”, (link opens a PDF) thus adoptions can become evangelical ‘missionary work’ (and potentially a suitable venue for “missionary funds”.)

More generally, there are those who view adoption itself as part of bringing children/so called “orphans” into “the house of the Lord” such as Steven Curtis and Mary Beth Chapman’s Shaohannah’s Hope, this too is another form of missionary work. The foundation is one of many such, (gathered under umbrella organizations such as the Christian Alliance for Orphans,) focused upon recruiting churches to fund church member’s adoptions, or “building the church” through adoption by way of “adoption ministries,” as a form of christian movement growth.

Perhaps the single most notable aspect of the adoption for movement growth schemes is that unlike most adoptions which are individual families making individual decisions, adoption for movement growth is marketing and resources geared towards mass adoptions, many people pooling resources so that many families can adopt as a means to benefit the entire structure. Lest one be quick to dismiss such, contemplate what has historically happened when religious groups decide to harness the power of the state for their political purposes.

Finally, there are those who simply stick their virtual palm out on the web and ask for cash to fund their adoption, usually via Paypal. For those who feel the need for a little more reciprocity while handing over the cash via Paypal, you’ll find couples using any number of gimmicks such as adopt-a-pixel. (Their about page is pretty standard.)

In any case, the above focuses upon the financial encouragement of adoption on the individual family level with structures such as government and private industry providing financial incentives, but there are additional financial incentives within the state adoption system itself.

States that are able to move larger numbers of kids out of foster care and into adoptions are given financial bonuses. Larger monetary rewards are available for placing kids deemed “special needs” (which yes, by definition, in some jurisdictions is going to include newborns and infants who pass through the “safe haven”/legalized child abandonment apparatus.)

The incentives to the states (& District), initially created under the Adoption and Safe Families Act of 1997 had expired back at the end of September of this year, but have just been reauthorized and now expanded under the (just signed) Fostering Connections to Success and Increasing Adoptions Act of 2008. The new law provides special financial incentives moving older kids faster, and increases the existing bonuses for placing “special needs” kids. Additionally states (& the District) are now required to notify those adopting, or considering adopting a foster child about the adoption tax credit.

The problem is, these incentives are based purely on the numbers, quantity not quality. States (and the District) earn bonuses purely on moving kids, not on whether or not these are good placements nor whether or not the placement is what’s best for the child.

Now coming back around to kids entering the system under the legalized child abandonment laws (dump laws/baby Moses laws/”safe haven” laws,) these same financial incentives will also apply to any kids adopted after being legally abandoned.

Legalized child abandonment at the local level has in actuality built a new door into the child welfare system. As in most states, the abandoner is considered ‘anonymous’, the infants (as all states other than Nebraska focus on either ‘newborns’ or ‘infants’) enter the system as essentially tabla rasa (blank slate) kids. They come with no ‘baggage’, usually no cultural history, nor medical history, no ‘pesky’ birthparents to be easily found at a later date, and in some cases no fathers (as the dump laws run roughshod right over many father’s parental rights.)

Perhaps most importantly, no high price tag. Why? Because once dumped they are wards of the state, usually placed in temporary foster care until a permanent adoptive family can be arranged for them.

Adoptions out of foster care can come at low to no cost to prospective adoptive families. Through the process, as I’ve documented above there’s an (et-hem), WEALTH of resources available to couples wishing to adopt dumped kids, and once adopted, the state may in fact pay them through ongoing monthly subsidies for taking the kid, up to potentially age 21.

At a time when international adoptions are undergoing constrictions with countries closing and agency consolidation, the dump laws provide a new domestic source. Not just any domestic source, a source that will provide some number of HWIs.

One of the biggest questions surrounding the dump laws relates to the redistribution of the now state collected kids. Are they being adopted in an equitable to all comers manner, or is there a certain degree of ‘line-jumping’ favouritism playing out in who gets them? Many couples wait long years for a child, while others, often with personal or political connections have been able to rapidly adopt the ‘dumplings’.

Rather than going for top dollar out on the open market, the state will actually end up paying couples to adopt them in a perfect storm of inverse economics.

We’re back to how words like foster care, or “special needs” take on whole new meanings when applied to the legally abandoned kids. These ‘foster adoptions’ or “special needs” adoptions will be often be of healthy white infants, the single most sought after commodities in the adoption market. Adopters will be paid to take them off the state’s hands, month after month.

With a deal that sweet who the hell needs stretch marks and childbirth?

Thursday, October 9, 2008

First out of state child abandonment, numbers spin, & upcoming public hearing announced

Nebraska, meet your neighboring state, Iowa.

Tuesday, Nebraska’s legalized child abandonment law took its latest inevitable twist, a 14 year-old Council Bluffs Iowa girl was brought across the Missouri River and abandoned at an Omaha’s Creighton University Medical Center.

Nebraska CFS proceeded to shit the proverbial brick, calling up the Iowa child abuse hotline and making a formal report in hopes of having the girl’s guardian prosecuted in Iowa:

Todd Landry, director of the state’s Children and Family Services, said the safe-haven law’s legal protections may not apply in this case because the girl is from Iowa, and whoever abandoned the 14-year-old might be prosecuted in that state.

“We have made a formal report of the abandonment to the Iowa child abuse hot line,” Landry said in a statement issued Tuesday night. “We are working with the Iowa Department of Human Services to resolve this situation as quickly as possible.”

Despite the broadly worded nature of the Nebraska law, those dealing with the day to day practicalities of it’s implementation see the writing on the wall, if they don’t do SOMETHING asap, to stem the tide, Nebraska will indeed, enter the national consciousness as a dumping ground of kids of any age. (I can just see the vacation postcards now, “Nebraska, where your kids can become memories!”)

This was nothing if not predictable. And yes, predicted, long before the law went into effect.

What the Nebraska legislature failed to grasp was that upon unleashing this child welfare fiasco, they made their state a NATION-WIDE dumping ground for kids. There’s nothing in the Nebraska law that prevents anyone ( see the “physical custody”clarification at the bottom of this Bastardette blog post) from anywhere showing up, kid in tow, and leaving them at any approved Nebraska dump site.

Now Nebraska wants those who dump in their state prosecuted in their home states. Yeah, good luck with that. After all, such would mean for example, those gambling in Vegas, upon returning home to a state where gambling is not legal being prosecuted for their activities in Nevada!

For those of you counting, she’s abandoned kid number 20, if you count the police station (unauthorized child dump site) dump, the 18 year-old who ‘abandoned’ himself under the Nebraska law, and the redirected dump that turned into a psych ward commitment at the urging of a Lincoln police officer, none of which are included in the Nebraska DHHS legalized abandonment stats as they are attempted, but not tabulated child dumps.

As the numbers grow, the numbers spin increases, resulting in articles headlined misleadingly, 9th Safe Haven Case Reported Tuesday.

Just as I posited in my previous post, clearly there are those who wanted to dump or were even attempting to dump, who were instead redirected. The attempted dumps are left unreported, other than a pair of mentions in passing:

Emergency room nurses at Saint Elizabeth Medical Center said they believe they have averted three potential Safe Haven cases since the law went into affect in July.

This belongs alongside the quote used in my previous post:

Casady says this is the second time LPD has helped a family considering using the safe haven law.

This is in the context of an officer talking a dumping guardian out of dumping and into committing the teen to the hospital’s psych ward instead.

These two quotes allude to potentially four more cases that would have resulted in child abandonments under the law had it not been for the intervention of hospital staff or police.

This is only what is ‘visible’, the few bits and pieces reported in local media. How many other ‘near-dumps’ have occurred is simply an unknown.

Nebraska hospitals are reporting phone calls from relatives wanting to bring in kids:

“People are calling up, ‘Can I bring my child or my nephew to the emergency room? we need help,’” emergency director Libby Raetz said.

As the numbers of legally abandoned children in Nebraska continues to rise, the Nebraska Legislature’s Judiciary and Health and Human Services committees have announced a joint public hearing on the legalized child abandonment law:

The Legislature’s Judiciary and Health and Human Services committees plan to hold a joint public hearing on the safe-haven law on Nov. 13.

Gov. Dave Heineman has not ruled out calling a special session of the Legislature to fix the law, but he has been reluctant to do so.

“The governor remains hopeful that a special session won’t be needed, but this issue must be addressed immediately at the beginning of the next session,” Heineman’s spokeswoman Jen Rae Hein said Wednesday.

From Lawmakers Schedule Safe Haven Hearing:

With new evidence almost daily that Nebraska’s Safe Haven law is having unintended consequences, Senator Brad Ashford, chairman of the Nebraska Legislature’s Judiciary Committee and Sen. Joel Johnson, chairman of the Health and Human Services Committee, Tuesday announced a hearing.

The joint hearing will be held to allow the public to comment on two key issues. The first issue: the use of the Safe Haven Law by parents and guardians since the bill went into effect and the need for possible amendments.

The second issue: what resources are available to children living in crisis, the process a parent or guardian must follow to access that help and whether any of this needs changing.

The hearing will be held November 13th at 1:30 p.m. in room 1113 of the State Capitol.

(the piece then goes on to list the DHHS officially abandoned under the law count.)

Not to be outdone, Nebraska’s Governor, Dave Heineman, released a statement yesterday. See Nebraska Governor’s statement on safe haven law (link opens a PDF) for the full text.

Among other details we have confirmation from the governor that none of the kids dumped was in “immediate danger”:

Children from eight families have been left at hospitals under the safe haven law. None of the children involved were infants and none was in immediate danger. While they cannot be charged for abandoning a child, parents and guardians using Nebraska’s safe haven law can be charged for other offenses. Courts are also likely to require parents and guardians to participate in parenting classes, family therapy, conflict resolution or other services in an effort to reunite youth with their families. Child support payments may be ordered while children are in state custody.

We also get the reiteration that the state may try to collect child support out of the abandoned kid’s guardian while the kid is in custody. These comments echo the Nebraska DHHS press release put out Sept. 26th, Safe Haven Law Does Not Absolve Parents of Responsibility.

The Governor’s statement continues:

Abandonment of an older child is potentially very devastating. Human services professionals have highlighted the difference in giving up a baby who will grow up knowing their birth family wanted a better life for them versus the impact of a parent giving up on an older child.

There are so many incorrect assumptions in this I scarcely know where to begin.

Abandonment of ANY child is devastation.

Just because an infant is not old enough to have a first hand account of the event, that hardly means they will not be affected deeply by it throughout their lifetime.

The primary difference between the abandoned infant’s perspective and the abandoned child’s perspective is in whether or not they remember and have an existing INTERPERSONAL relationship with those previous family members. It is important to remember than A relationship exists between them whether they have ever spent time together or remember one another or not. The permanent loss of that family, even if not personally remembered through an abandoned child’s first hand accounts does not mean that loss is something moved past with ease.

Speaking as an adopted adult who lives behind the wall of sealed records, although I may not have personal memories of my family of origin, that hardly means they somehow matter less to me.

Further, the personal information cut through that break in ties, the child’s identity ‘rights’, heritage, and cultural context, genetic, etc is a lifelong loss. In practical terms, it means living a lifetime without access to the kinds of information other citizens take for granted.

The role of the state, rather than encouraging the loss of such, should instead be to protect those citizens most vulnerable and most unable to speak out on behalf of their own interests. Make no mistake about it, speaking personally, as the living result of another form of child welfare social experimentation, when the state intentionally deprives infants of those bedrock assumptions that other citizens simply have, the state is causing lifelong harm. It deprives people of information, while they are infants, and the effects will echo down through the lifetimes of the class of people directly affected, their families, and their own children.

“Wanted a better life for them” is also another coded piece of language adopted people are all too familiar with.

The more we began to uncloak the secrecy surrounding the circumstances of our own relinquishments is the more we found the real reasons very few womyn relinquish their children to adoption, most womyn would keep their children if only they could. We were often surrendered due to to lack of resources and poverty, as well as the climate of shame inflicted on many pregnant womyn, the young, the poor, those whose families reject them.

To our horror, some of us have found parents who were not consenting parties. Womyn forced to sign papers, fathers simply left out of the equation altogether, other extended family members desperate to ‘keep up apperances’ and ‘make the problem/baby just go away’ pushing relinquishment as the ‘only answer’. To say nothing of industry pressure.

As Nebraska’s current dump law allows anyone with ‘physical custody’ to dump, and to date we’ve seen extended family dumping, questions of consent remain by and large unaddressed for some parties who may well have their legal rights trampled in the process.

Pushing the age limit in Nebraska down from any “child” under age 19, down to ‘newborns’ still does nothing to change the situations of those utilizing the legalized child abandonment laws, it takes the kid out of the equation, but structural issues such as poverty, lack of adequate child care, domestic violence, health care costs, etc remain intact.

Infant abandonment laws make the perfect cover for incest, hidden pregnancy, secret birth, then just dump the ‘evidence’.

Legalized child abandonment laws are harmful to womyn, to families, to communities, and most importantly, to the children themselves.

Again I’m stating the obvious, legalized child abandonment is clearly not pro-child.

To date, no state has ever shown conclusively that any child abandoned under this scheme was ever in immediate danger of being killed.

Just as we’ve seen in Nebraska, more often than not those abandoning the kids feel they have no other options and care deeply about the kids. They often view dumping them as a way of ‘protecting’ them, going so far as to in at least one case, insist after using the legalized abandonment apparatus that the mother still loved her son and wanted him to understand that she didn’t abandon him, and that she still wanted to see him. (Cognitive dissonance in the extreme.)

These are not those at risk of leaving babies in dumpsters.

Those who utilize the laws are simply entering the child welfare and adoption system through a newly created second door. A door that requires little to no paperwork, and has no waiting time to actually rid oneself of the kid. The ultimate in instant gratification abandonment.

As most states legalized child abandonment laws leave the womyn utilizing them anonymous, it has been impossible to build a profile of a ‘typical’ womyn who abandons her child under them. That said, while most states baby Moses laws marketing is aimed at ‘young girls’ often still in school, what little data can be culled from news reports etc, shows a very different profile, that of an older, often desperate womyn, sometimes married, sometimes with other kids.

Aging down Nebraska’s dump law to a 2.0 version narrowed to newborns still avoids the core issues those using the dump laws face.

Insisting over and over again ‘there is help out there’ while pointing the desperate into private faith based programs is again, the state abandoning its own responsibilities to its citizens.

The Governor closes with the following, making it clear what he wants to see is ‘infant’-based dump laws:

The few situations we’ve seen so far demonstrate the need for a change in Nebraska’s safe haven law. In the coming legislative session, I will advocate for changes that put the focus back on protecting an infant in danger. That should be our priority.

While this would ensure the infants- eventual kids- eventual adults will be silenced for a few years at least, all such a bill would really do is push back the timing on when the unresolved issues with the dump laws would begin to surface in that second batch of Nebraska dumpees.

Just as it took adoptees the time it takes infants to grow to age of majority, that 18 year-lag, and then those affected by the sealing of adoption records legislation in various states began to organize against sealed records, I predict the children of legalized abandonments will also face that 18 year-lag, and then begin to organize against what what done to them.

Every single day that these dump laws are in place is a day that yet more kids may suffer irrepiarable harm. The only genuine solution is full repeal.

The longer Nebraska politicians drag out debates about what is to be done is the larger the toll becomes, an ever increasing count of kids for whom the consequences are permanent.

I’ve already written about how the dump bills were built out of the structures fighting openness in adoption records.

Don’t condemn another generation to lives without the basic identity based building blocks they will need to live out their lives.

Learn from the example of what was done under the sealing of adoption records and the lifelong lasting legacy of harm that has caused, then understand, baby dump and child dump laws are just the latest structures built upon that flawed foundation.

As I’ve ended pretty much all my Nebraska dump law posts, I will continue to call for nothing short of the full repeal of legalized child abandonment laws.

They fail kids- for a lifetime.

UPDATE

Between the time I started this piece and finally posting it, the abandoned child from Iowa has since been sent back to Iowa. I suppose we can now label such a ‘return to sender’ abandonment. The 14 year-old is however, listed on Nebraska DHHS’s revised official count. (Link opens a PDF.)

Wednesday, October 8, 2008

INSANITY CONTINUES: IOWA TEEN DUMPED AT NEBRASKA HOSPITAL

Just when we thought it can't get any worse, it does! This just in from the Associated Press: 14-year old Iowa girl abandoned under Nebraska law."

Yes, folks, that's right. Now, they're hauling their unwanted kids in from out-of-state. According to the wire, the unfortunate girl is from Council Bluffs,Iowa, just across the state line from Omaha. She was abandoned--oh, excuse me--"safe havened"--at Creighton University Medical Center (where the 9 Statons were dumped last month) by her mother. No details have been released yet, but Nebraska DFS spokesperson Todd Landry says Nebraska law may not apply, since the girl and her mother are from out-of-state.

But why wouldn't it apply? There is nothing in the law that says no outsiders need apply.

Again, for late comers, here is the ENTIRE text of the law:

Section 1. No person shall be prosecuted for any crime based solely upon the act of leaving a child in the custody of an employee on duty at a hospital licensed by the State of Nebraska. The hospital shall promptly contact appropriate authorities to take custody of the child.

Parents are home free. No blame. No shame, No name. Oops! Scratch that last one! All of Nebraska's dumpess are preteens and teens. Can't have anonymity there!

As I wrote back on July 17, when the Nebraska law went into effect, in Nebraska Safe Haven Law: Tired of Your Kid? :

Actually on closer look, this isn't a "Baby Safe Haven" law at all. It's decriminalization of child abandonment dressed up in fashionable safe haven bombastia.

And that's what they they got. (I'll drop the pig and lipstick homily). Politicians and DFS can try to clean it up all they want. They can put out their press releases and hold their press conferences, and beg parents, "that's not what we really meant." But not only the horse, but the cows and the chickens and the pigs (with lipstick--ok, I lied!) are out of the barn.

State officials knew what they were doing. when they enacted HB 157. They admit it. (I'll write about that later). Now, they are shocked...shocked...that nearly 20 parents or "guardians" have taken them up on their offer to take their kids off their hands, no questions asked.

Todd Landry says DFS has sent a formal report on the Iowa dumpee to the Iowa child abuse hotline.

Hotline????? Can't DFS read their own law?

******

In my July 17, blog I also facetiously threatened to take my obnoxious teenage neighbor--the one who jumps on the hoods of cars at 3:00 AM (and I'm not making this up!)--on a road trip to Omaha. Since the governor and cronies seem reluctant to call a special session to repeal this crackpot bill I guess I still have time to ditch her. It's for her own good. And for the good of the neighbors. And it's better and cheaper than Ritalin.

I hate to be Trotskyte about this whole thing, but the longer this goes on, the easier it will be to discredit baby dump laws. THANK YOU NEBRASKA, for making our job that much easier. Implode, Baby, Implode!

Tuesday, October 7, 2008

MOTHER "ATTEMPTS" TO DUMP TEEN DAUGHTER IN NEBRASKA

More Nebraska Fiasco:

KOLN/KGIN-TV reports that a 34 year woman attempted to dump her 15-year old daughter at Bryan LGH West yesterday morning, under the state's safe haven law. Hospital officials talked her out of it, and admitted the teenager to the hospital's child psychiatric service.

According to the mother, the girl was a runaway. The mother says she'd begun paperwork to make her daughter a ward of the state, "but it took too long."

Let's hope this woman never has to fill out an insurance claim or buy a house!

How much worse does this have to get before the legislature, stops husking corn, and repeals this travesty? No, the law doesn't need tweaked or tightened-up or any other quaint-worded fix politicians want to throw about. The mass dumping of Nebraska's children is the perfect consequence of what we have been saying would happen for the last nine years.

Who's Next: Spouses? Grandparents?

How many families need to be destroyed before people wake up to the atrocity of "safe havens"?

I'll be writing much more about this, but I'm heading for downtown in a few minutes and wanted to get this breaking news up.

REPEAL BABY DUMP LAWS NOW!

START IN NEBRASKA AND SPREAD OUT!

TAKE BACK YOUR STATE NOW!


Another day, another attempted abandonment

More of the same, but with a new twist.

Quotes taken from Attempted Safe Haven Case:

…a 34 year old mother showed up at Bryan LGH West 11:15 Monday morning to drop off her 15 year old daughter under the state’s safe haven law. The woman told officials the daughter was a run-away and she couldn’t handle her behavior. The woman also told police she was worried for her young son when the girl was home and had begun filing paperwork to make the girl a ward of the state, but it was taking too long.

Once again, we run head long into one of the real reasons behind these child dumps, going the usual route just takes too long for some. Apparently it’s just too darn hard to get rid of a kid.

Poor thing!

But instead of going ahead with the abandonment, an officer talked the woman down to ‘merely’ having the girl committed to the hospital’s psych unit:

A Lincoln officer talked with the woman and doctors at the hospital and worked out an arrangement where the girl was admitted into the hospital’s child psychiatric service instead of abandoned under safe haven.

I guess all these dump stats are bringing too much attention and heat on Nebraska, they’re down to one on one trying to talk dumpers into alternatives that keep the kids out of the state’s stats.

As I said in yesterday’s post Nebraska- two 12 year-old boys legally abandoned this past weekend, & ‘gaming’ the numbers “Baby Love Child” being a bastard based blog, around here I focus on the experience of the kids themselves, and my numbers are going to reflect the number of kids attempted to be dumped not necessarily NE DHHS’s ‘dump accomplished’ count.

The piece goes on to point out, this is not the first time the Lincoln (Nebraska) Police Department has stepped in to divert dump bound familes:

Casady says this is the second time LPD has helped a family considering using the safe haven law.

So I guess the real question is, statewide, how many other attempted dumps have been redirected and may be going unreported?

Has Nebraska finally begun to reach the point of attempted spin control, trying to keep dump bound guardians from actually completing the child dump?

Clearly Nebraska officials understand the official number count is being watched, (yes you can subscribe to their “Safe haven” webpage). The official Nebraska DHHS count does not include a kid left at unauthorized location (a police station), nor the 18 year-old who tried to “safe haven” himself. Nor will the official tally include cases such as this girl, who but for Lincoln police intervention would have been legally abandoned (kid #19 if all attempted cases are included.) so the question arises, is there now an active effort to keep the numbers down/more cases out of the state stats?

The real answer to legalized abandonment is to for Nebraska legislators to realize that “safe haven” laws are no answer to the real problems kids and families face and repeal the law. They have an opportunity to lead the way, learning from Nebraska’s experimentation with legalized child abandonment, and step back away from this irresponsible form of legislation, back into the realm of actual kid-based social support structures.

Am I holding my breath for full repeal? Unfortunately no.

Why? Because odds are good that rather than doing right by Nebraska’s kids and families and repealing the law, state lawmakers are instead going to go for a round two ‘dump law 2.0′, trying to monkey with the age requirements on legalized child abandonments, which will only end up screwing kids younger and less vocal (for the time being.)

Further, baby dump laws have dire consequences for womyn, encouraging them to hide their pregnancies, ecshew prenatal care, and give birth secretly (endangering their own lives) in hopes of being able to ‘make the problem go away’ via legalized baby dumping.

Nebraska has the opportunity to step up and say ‘no more, we don’t and won’t abandon children (and womyn) that way here’. It has an opportunity to take the leadership position of sending the clear message that in Nebraska at least, THIS state does not encourage child abandonment.

But odds are they’ll opt for what they see as the easy way out, and just go for the aged down version. The damage will continue.

And that’s the real shame, that not a single state is willing to buck the baby-dumping trend to say no, we don’t dump our kids around here.

It is legal to dump newborns in all 50 states.

To our shame.

Bastardette has also blogged about the latest attempted dump, MOTHER ‘ATTEMPTS” TO DUMP TEEN DAUGHTER IN OMAHA. I’ll just close with her wise words:

How much worse does this have to get before the legislature, stops husking corn, and repeals this travesty? No, the law doesn’t need tweaked or tightened-up or any other quaint-worded fix politicians want to throw about. The mass dumping of Nebraska’s children is the perfect consequence of what we have been saying would happen for the last nine years.

How many more kids have to be abandoned before states begin to listen?